When a viewer asks John if he plans on shaving his beard, Rachael answers more quickly than he does—and John calls it his favorite question of the year.

"You're very handsome without a beard," Rach says, "but I love your beard—and more importantly, John loves his beard, so we don't want to do anything to disrupt the Johnness of John."

MORE: Was Rachael's Husband John Ever a Bartender? Yes—And So Was Rach!